It’s 1881. The International Cotton Exposition is coming to Atlanta. But across the city, leading black entrepreneurs are being brutally murdered, the letter M inscribed on their mutilated bodies. Former Atlanta police officer Thomas Canby, disgraced and relegated to a country post where he can enjoy fine whiskey and a slower pace of life, is brought back to Atlanta to work the case. Partnered up with the force’s first black officer, Cyrus Underwood, Canby searches for the killer and also comes up against The Ring, organizers of the Cotton Exposition and also the men who ran him out of town. Such is the plot of Matthew Guinn’s novel The Scribe.
The novel, while not long, progresses slowly, action and murder notwithstanding. It’s difficult to feel too much for Canby either way, though the brutality visited upon every character about whom Canby cares seems gratuitous and is deeply troubling. The story, however, lacks depth. It plods along and the mystery contains less mysteriousness—and less appeal—than one would expect from a novel with such a perfect setup. The writing is pleasant and it’s clear that Guinn has invested time in researching the world about which he writes, but The Scribe, unfortunately, falls a bit short of its promise.
However, as it’s the second novel in a series, which will most probably contain more installments, there’s still room for improvement, and there’s a definite chance that Guinn will be able to pull his characters and world together in a manner that makes them more multidimensional and sympathetic than is managed in this book.
Ashley McCall is a reviewer supreme, the kind of reviewer that comes once in a lifetime—at least, once in her own lifetime. An MFA graduate with a degree in creative writing (emphasis in screenwriting) who now spends her days working near the very top of a downtown skyscraper, she enjoys books of all genres, preferring the beauty of language to explosive plots, but harboring a not-so-secret love for smart, well-written detective and crime novels. Originally from the San Francisco Bay Area, she currently resides in Los Angeles, where, despite her graduate degree, she does NOT possess a secret desire to break into the entertainment industry. In her free time, she enjoys trying new restaurants and breweries, travel, long romantic walks on the beach, and writing intentionally bad poetry to submit for publication.
Santa Montefiore’s The Daughters of Ireland is a gorgeous, sweepingly romantic tale of love and loss. Following The Girl in the Castle, this is Montefiore’s second book featuring the Deverill family. Set in the 1920s, Montefiore tells the [...]
The Baker’s Secret focuses on the small French coastal town of Vergers. World War II submerges the town with German soldiers and Jewish persecution. Emma apprenticed with the town’s master baker until she was hauled off to a prison camp. Emma is [...]
Vera St. John’s life has always been at least partially defined by the looming shadow of her mother, Mary. A troubled woman with an infamous past, Vera loved and feared her mother in equal parts. After she is removed from her mother’s care, Vera [...]