So You Want to Get Your Book Reviewed. Here’s Where Most Authors Go Wrong.

by | Mar 12, 2026 | Articles, Book Marketing, Resources for Writers

The submission pile at most professional book review services is enormous. Your book is in it, probably alongside a few thousand others. Here’s how to not waste your spot.

Not Reading the Guidelines

It sounds obvious. It isn’t widely practiced. Most submission rejections come from books that don’t fit the outlet’s genre scope, length requirements, or publication window. Read the guidelines before you submit. Then re-read them.

Powell’s doesn’t shelve books under ‘self-discovery.’ It shelves them under mystery, fiction, or narrative nonfiction. Every review outlet has a scope. Know yours.

Submitting Without a Usable Description

You have roughly 250 words to tell a reviewer what your book is. ‘A journey of self-discovery’ and ‘a story about love and loss’ are not descriptions. They’re the absence of a description.

Be specific: genre, central conflict, the thing that makes it this book and not a thousand others. That specificity is what gets a reviewer to say yes (and what gives them something to work with once they do).

The complete rundown of submission errors, including this one, is at getmybookreviewed.com/10-biggest-mistakes-authors-make-getting-book-reviewed. It covers 10 things professional reviewers see go wrong constantly. Worth checking before you hit send.

Treating the Review as the Endpoint

The review isn’t the destination. It’s the asset. Once you have it, you need to know what to do with it: quote it on Amazon, add it to your press kit, reference it in query letters, put it on your back cover in the next printing.

A review that sits on a website and doesn’t get circulated is doing a fraction of what it could.

Waiting Until After Launch

If you submit six months after publication, you’ve missed the editorial window at most services. Book review programs prioritize current releases. That’s just how the calendar works.

Portland Book Review accepts submissions on a rolling basis at portlandbookreview.com, with priority given to recently published titles. Standard reviews are $199. Free editorial submissions are available for books published within the last 90 days.

Submit early, submit specifically, and then actually use what you get.